PEMANDU is so used to shocking the nation with their claims, statistics and projection to sell their wares. When being shocked, it took them weeks, if not months, to respond. [Read Rocky Bru here and Kuala Lumpur Post here dated July 5th, 2012]
Idris Jala's reply for PEMANDU is merely a standard denial. It dismisses allegations and claim this and that without highlighting where the allegations are wrong. Basically, it has no news worthy substance.
It is his defense of Farah Intan, his claims are questionable.
Under attack
PEMANDU did try to answer their detractors through the Omar Ong friendly The Chronicles and Dato Idris Jala's series articles in The Star but it was only explaining and as said, it is not answering allegations and expose.
Why The Star which Helen Ang have continually exposed to be the mouthpiece of DAP? Is it because PEMANDU is only interested to tell their side of the story to their converted left-leaning and liberals?
Since Syed Akbar's damning posting on August 29th [read here], there was another set of expose on a staff of PEMANDU by The Benchmark here and Syed Akbat here that shocked PEMANDU.
The "establishment' attempted to fight back the few pro-UMNO bloggers questioning the integrity and competency of PEMANDU. These campaign have catched on and political columnist like Joceline Tan have touched on the PEMANDu attack in her recent column [read here.]
Their pathetic attempt was to label bloggers attacking PEMANDU as anti Najib.
Syed Akbar, who denied he has burned his bridges with Najib [read here], answered back by exposing PEMANDU Twitter promoting pro-opposition Loyar Buruk group. It also affirm PEMANDU staff's neo-liberal leaning and disloyalty to Najib. [read here]
Idris Jala's first page reply below:
It is all denial and claim they have system and process in taking in staff.
Idris Jala basically try to say that as an organisation that is supposed to improve performance delivery that they are practising the system they believe will improve performace delivery. But unfortunately, they used the quantitatively skewed, mechanically driven and now much discredited KPI system.
Note the part they are 100% committed to delivering results for the government. Are the words of Idris trustable?
Did Idris Jala delivered the results for MAS when he chopped 3,000 staff under MCC and ridiculously rehired back 3,000 know nuts about aviation newbies? No... he had an operational loss but lied to say MAS had record profit. He was subsequently fired after our expose.
Did he really did turnaround when he was in Shell? No... he was merely doing textbook turnaround to butcher staff that he is known as Butcher from Shell. True turnaround specialist are operation man who knows how to truly cut wastage and improve efficiency.
Defending Farah
Idris defended Farah gallantly:
Still very much standard reply devoid of information and details to say Farah had conducted herself to the rules and regulations all staff of Prime Minister's Department supposed to adhere.
Someone conversant in the code of conduct for civil service can easily debunked that claim to defend her personal conduct outside office. There are many civil servants in our family!
Commendable KPI?
Idris claimed her performance have been KPI-ed as commendable. Is it really so?
The promiscuosly pictured Farah Intan is a Senior Analyst in charge of crime. She must have been a party to the process to recommend Emergency Ordinance and Internal Security Act was abolished to pacify the opposition and pro-opposition NGOs before the general election.
Farah was not the PENASIHAT but since Transformation is the agenda of PEMANDU and political transformation is also on the menu. Abolishing EO and ISA was also intended as part of political transformation.
Sources confirmed to this blogger that Dato Omar Ong, the hidden hand behind and with office at PEMANDU, convinced the Prime Minister to do so. Farah may have helped prepared the paper and talking points.
To know how commendable Farah is, read this Bernama report, below:
K'jaan cadang pasang EMD pada penjenayah SOSMA bulan depan
10:04PM Ogos 24 2013
Kementerian Dalam Negeri (KDN) bercadang menggunakan peranti pengawasan elektronik (EMD) ke atas penjenayah tertentu yang ditahan di bawah Akta Kesalahan Keselamatan (Langkah-Langkah Khas) 2012 (SOSMA) pada akhir bulan depan.
Peguam Negara Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail mengesahkan bahawa kerajaan telah meluluskan pemasangan EMD bagi mengesan suspek jenayah terancang dan kejam bagi memastikan mereka tidak melakukan jenayah lain semasa dalam jaminan.
"Bagi saya, adalah lebih baik jika EMD ini dapat dilaksanakan dengan segera," katanya kepada pemberita selepas menyampaikan ucapan khas di Forum Pencegahan Jenayah di Petaling Ja;ya hari ini.
Abdul Gani mengulas komen penganalisis kanan Unit Pelaksanaan dan Pengurusan Prestasi (Pemandu), Farah Intan Burhanudin, bahawa peranti itu akan digunakan terhadap suspek yang ditahan dalam Ops Cantas.
Dalam forum itu, Farah Intan berkata peranti tersebut, yang digunakan di banyak negara termasuk Amerika Syarikat sejak 1994, akan mengurangkan risiko pesalah berulang dan memainkan peranan penting dalam penguatkuasaan polis secara berkesan.
"Peranti itu juga kos efektif dan mendorong kepada pengurangan masalah kesesakan dalam penjara," katanya ketika membentangkan inisiatif semasa dan masa depan Pemandu dalam membendung jenayah.
Dalam ucapannya, Abdul Gani berkata Malaysia tidak memerlukan undang-undang pencegahan bagi membendung jenayah serius kerana negara mempunyai pasukan polis yang bagus untuk menangani jenayah dengan berkesan dan cekap.
"Saya mempunyai kepercayaan penuh terhadap polis untuk melakukan tugas tanpa memerlukan undang-undang pencegahan. Ini terbukti apabila mereka (polis) membuktikan kemampuan mengendalikan jenayah sejak beberapa minggu lepas.
"Oleh itu, saya mendapati sukar untuk alasan secara rasional sebab-sebab mengapa kita perlu memperkenalkan semula undang-undang seperti Akta Keselamatan Dalam Negeri (ISA) dan Ordinan Darurat (EO)," katanya.
Walaupun undang-undang pencegahan baru akan dibentangkan di sesi Parlimen akan datang, Abdul Gani berkata Jabatan Peguam Negara akan mengkaji semua sebarang pindaan dan input daripada pelbagai pihak.
Beliau berkata jika negara benar-benar memerlukan undang-undang pencegahan bagi membanteras jenayah berat maka satu kajian menyeluruh dan cadangan terhadap undang-undang ini perlu dipertimbangkan secara teliti.
Memetik kes penjenayah kejam Botak Chin pada tahun 70-an, Abdul Gani berkata Peguam Negara ketika itu berjaya menyelesaikan kes itu dan mensabitkan hukuman ke atas penjenayah itu tanpa menggunakan undang-undang pencegahan (ISA atau EO) tetapi hanya menguna pakai undang-undang biasa.
Ditanya pendirian beliau memperkenalkan semula EO, beliau berkata: "Pendirian saya tetap sama."
Read on in Malaysiakini here.
Two and half year in PEMANDU and she is deliveraing a presentation in a seminar as though she is an expert? Gani Patail was giving government and PEMANDU a hand but in an earlier report by NST, there were mixed opinion. Read below:
13 August 2013
Pemandu to study usage of tracking devices
By ADIB POVERA AND BALQIS LIM | news@nst.com.my
CRIME PREVENTION: Govt mulling its use on recidivists at early stage
KUALA LUMPUR: THE Performance and Delivery Unit (Pemandu) is conducting a study on the effectiveness of the electronic-monitoring device used in several other countries to reduce crime.
Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Nancy Shukri said Pemandu was studying the models adopted by the United States and other countries, which had used electronic devices on prisoners under parole and repeat offenders.
"Pemandu is looking into the matter.
"The unit will study the systems used in other countries, such as the US and Singapore, to understand how the device can help to curb crime.
"We will make a complete analysis to decide if we should go ahead with introducing the electronic-monitoring device."
Nancy, however, said should the government proceed with the implementation of the tracking device, it would be applied to recidivists during the initial stage of implementation.
She was commenting on the government's plan to fit tracking devices on former Emergency Ordinance (EO) detainees, many of whom were linked with the recent spate of murders.
The approach was one of the options considered by the government in managing those with a tendency to commit serious crime, apart from the proposed legislation of tougher laws to prevent crime.
The proposal received mixed reviews from legal experts and criminologists.
Although the plan to fit detainees with tracking devices is seen as an innovative approach, experts doubt its effectiveness against hardcore criminals and gangland members.
Senior lawyer Ragunath Kesavan said the tracking device would be an useful tool in tackling serious crime.
"The device would allow the person detained to only go to specific areas."
On opinions that there were no laws to allow the government to slap prisoners and detainees with the device, Ragunath said it was not necessary.
"The court is entitled to enforce the admission to set bail and is allowed to specify the terms and conditions of bail to the detainees.
"Therefore, no laws are required to make them wear the tracking anklets," he said, adding that no human rights issue would be violated if it was related to criminal proceedings.
Another senior lawyer, however, had reservations about the system. Yeo Yeng Poh said in the US, the device would be used on those who had been convicted or are undergoing parole.
"Individuals under house arrest or under parole and those who are sentenced but requested to serve their terms outside prison are often required to wear the ankle monitor.
"But here, if the government is linking the detainees with serious crime, they should not just be made to wear the tracking devices, but should instead be charged with the crime."
His views were supported by prominent criminologist Associate Professor Dr P. Sundramoorthy.
"I know that the devices have been used in Singapore and the US.
"However, I believed the device would only be suitable for first-time offenders and those who commit non-serious crimes.
"I do not think the device would help to reduce organised crime."
Musa was asked of the EMD in a close door function. He said that he had proposed this when he was IGP when there were legal provisions to do. He said, "Sekarang apa ada cerita?"
Upon checking with several police officers at Bukit Aman, there said PEMANDU did not consulted with the police. This PEMANDU Senior Analayst proposed to the government without consultation with the police.
Why?
No consultation made with the releveant party and we, policeman and Road Motor Vehicle, are directed to implement it and when it failed, government will takeover from the two companies.
Is it true Omar have interest in the two companies, Mustapha Ong? He has been going around town telling his son has interest in the company.
The sceptical police high official said PEMANDU will direct us without consultation to implement and there will be someone getting some "Chinese businessman" to supply for cheap and sold at inflated price to government officers by supplier.
He added on, then the "Chinese businessman" will help release EMD-ed gangster for a price and the whole program would be made meaningless.
Already murderers had outstmart the device. Read here.
If Farah had not consulted the police or Musa Hassan, wonder where did she get the idea of EMD.
From a movie?
Or by plagarising Musa Hassan proposal and claiming as her's?
Or while under intoxication on the streets of Kuala Lumpur or from too much cocktail by the beach?
Personal conduct outside work does affect work performance. Itu pun tak faham ke Idris Jala? Tak habis-habis kaki kelentong....
Bet if presurred to reveal amount consultancy fee, it will be the same style of answer. PEMANDU yang perlu ditransformasi dari menjawab stail lama.
27 comments:
improve performance delivery ...err this referring to between two legs?
Is the guy now driving Malaysia GTS down the slippery Genting slope, THE SAME GUY WHO FLEW THE RIKETY MAS AND SAID EVERY A OK ? You know this guy looks he required some 8 hours sleep always.
Malaysia's own version of rasputin. When will najib ever wake up?
FYI..I heard someone said that the PM looks up on Idris Jala. He said the guy is a genius and has helped a lot. He must be surrounded by idiots that he takes Idris Jala as the smartest. Please dont stop whacking Pemandu. They must go and they must go fast.
Najib..... All your advisors has failed you and yet you still want to keep them using rakyat money after 4 years you in power
Where is your common sense Najib....
Wait till your downfall and the same advisora will abandon you one by one
Remember it is the voter umno members and the rakyats that put you at where you are now... And not these advisors
.
If all employees in Pemandu appointed on Merit, how the hell this fella, Ahmad Suhaili, with NO PROVEN track record on public transport and can become the Director of Urban Public Transport and Greater KL. His failed short stint in IRDA or his disaster contribution in SKS Venture or his happy time with Idris Jala in SHELL?
Yes I agree Tuan Syed, the turnaround specialists including some external consultants that Idris hired during the lab exercises - contacts during his SHELL days or ex shell staff, "True turnaround needs an understanding of operations or getting your hands dirty". Idris has not turned MAS around and it is only when a CEO leaves that one sees the damage he has done. There are too many powerpoint CEOs around these days, including perhaps some in political office who love seeing powerpoints. I am not fed up of Idris Jala, but i am fed up of cronies and close contacts without qualifications getting the opportunities and jobs.
What about the rest of us - of any race in Malaysia, those of us who are committed, creative, dedicated and skilfull but without the PPE/Oxbridge or without the friends of friends background...how the bloody hell do we "change the stars"
P.B.
Here I would like to propose the PM to appoint Syed Akbar as Adviser against Pemandu. His function is to review and comments all proposal submitted by Pemandu before being implemented.
The best way in solving this problems is by eliminating Najib and his hardcore cronies - the sooner the better for the country
PEMANDU memang banyak buat kerja memandai.
Apa budak Farah kaki bool ni tau pasal kerja polis jika dia ni sampai kena denda pasal drunk driving?
Patut bincang dengan polis yang lebih tahu.
Brader
How about doing a public poll on pemandu kpi.
Thats the only way to shake najib up.
All these people suka syok sendiri dan tidak berpijak di bumi nyata
I understand the Pemandu employs 9 young Chinamen of dubious origins with no knowledge of local public affairs.
Guys pls give Ms Farah a break...a bit more exposure and we'll see her pix on the beach with less than a bikini (a rather intellectually-stimulating thot indeed)! Afterall, isnt she the brilliant anti-crime expert whose vast experience spans all of...TWO years! And, if after having looked at her pics, for some reason you are thinking of a common GRO, pls cease & desist. She has, i shall remind you, been called to the BAR!
I seriously wonder why do you have a bone to pick against Idris Jala and his Pemandu.
I do not know him or Pemandu or how good or bad they are but there're also some why speak highly of them.
That makes me wonder why are you strenuously trying to run him down.
Story has it that with this letter, the girl's bad attitude has gotten worse at the office because management is backing her up; she is feeling untouchable now.
PEMANDU senior management is lowsy. Communication management gurus will recommend that when corporate reputation is at stake, senir management must enaure their visibility in handling it. Instead, they ask media to deal with an analyst (lower rank than this farah girl). Bosses no balls ke? Cannot control staff decorum and have the cheek to tell other govt officers to buck-up.
No wonder Malaysia is sinking... Management supports a drunk girl instead of chastising her.
Like this, how to pandu country if they cannot pandu one drunk girl.
Habisla camni...
i love the scene man....with seaview background!
and i may sit near a bullshit watching flies over it.
Dereba Pencen
Johor
appointed based on merit???
graduated from UIAM with 2nd class lower tu bagus sangat ke?!
For info....
1- 1st class
2- 2nd class upper
3- 2nd class lower (= 3rd class laa)
4- General degree
2nd class lower tu rank dia no 2 dari bawah bukan no2 dari atas
Breaking news....
Untuk mengimbangi keluhan rakyat golongan pertengahan dan bawahan kerana kenaikan harga minyak minggu lepas, PEMANDU telah mencadangkan kepada Najib agar semua harga kereta dengan kapasiti 1600cc dan kebawah di kurangkan sebanyak 20sen.
Finally....Tq pemandu.
Cyber bullying at its best. Pot calling the kettle black etc. while we may disagree on what she does in private, putting people's photos on cyberspace with the intention of embarrassing her just shows how some people are willing to stoop so low to earn extra mileage for their political masters. Malulah sikit.
Actually, Anonymous 9.37 pm, it was the girl herself who put up those pictures online.
And please.. don't even start on the "they were private pictures bla bla" argument. Anyone with the slightest semblance of sense knows that once you upload pictures to Facebook, your right to privacy pretty much extinguishes itself. I feel sorry that this happened to her, but the fact is - she walked right into this.
I, for one, am glad that Pemandu is being called out by the bloggers. Who cares who their political masters are? At least someone's watching.
Actually, Anonymous 9.37 pm, it was the girl herself who put up those pictures online.
And please.. don't even start on the "they were private pictures bla bla" argument. Anyone with the slightest semblance of sense knows that once you upload pictures to Facebook, your right to privacy pretty much extinguishes itself. I feel sorry that this happened to her, but the fact is - she walked right into this.
I, for one, am glad that Pemandu is being called out by the bloggers. Who cares who their political masters are? At least someone's watching.
Kita tidak memerlukan Agenda Bumiputera. apa yang kita perlukan adala Agenda Kemerdekaan Nasional yang akan mengekangk ketamakkan golongan kapitai Cina dan India. Ini sama laha mcma New Economic Policy ia merangkumi hal ehwal nasional.
Agenda Kemerdakaan Nasional akan menetapkan
1. hak-hak orang Cina tidak boleh melebihi 20% aset negara
2. hak-hak orang India tidak boleh melehbehi 10% aset negara.
Ini adalah Persekutuan Tanah Melayu jadi kita perlu ada polisi nasional untuk mengawal kekayaan kaum pendatang cina dan India.
3. Gas dan petrol dan diesel petronas perlu diagihkan sama rata untuk semua kaum asal, Melayu dan bumiputera Sabah dan Sarawak.
4. Chinese exclusion clause seperti di US perlu di adakan untuk menjaga sekuriti Persekutuan dari pencerobohan kerajaan Cina dan Cina Singapura.
5. Tanah dan hutan tropika adalah hak Persekekutuan dan pendatang Cina dan India tidak boleh memiliki tanah in perpetuiti.
6. Wasiat Raja-Raja Melayu perlu diambil sebagai peramble kepada pembacaan Perlembagaan di mana di sebutkan 50% tanah adalah untuk orang Melayu. Dan bakinya dibahagikan dengan kaum lain.
7. Pembentukan PEMANDU adalah salah dari segi Perlembagaan dan wasiat Raja-Raja Melayu kerana di anggotai oleh majoriti orang Kristian dan India dan Cina yang kononnya lebih pandai (merit konon) sebab itu mereka di pilih oleh Presiden UMNO. Bahlol!
Ramai lagi Cina dan India yang pandai atau orang Rusia dan Inggeris yang kita boleh bayar. Jadieder ini adalah pariah yang tidak boleh dipakai oleh orang Melayu untuk menetapkan arah jalan Tanah Melayu.
Bubarkan PEMANDU!!!
Sarawak haruslah keluar Dari Malaysia & mentadbir negara baru macam singapore - no point of staying in Malaysia with culture racist sampah masyarakat Melayu Malaya Macam ni
Is this snubbed nose fellow the Malaysian version of the famied Harvard mafia of Indonesia ? We have no need for such folks who need the help of 9 young Chinamen of no origin and unqualified. All the Government needs to do is to be normal!
Hello Anonymous above.
It was the Malay who killed Duncan Stewart the colonised Governor that made the British withdraw from Sarawak.
It was the Sarawak malays who chose to join hands with the Malaya Malays.
It was the British who enrich and invite the chinese to Sarawak to the detriment of the natives.
Stop giving Sarawak logging licenses to Chinese!!
Sarawak timber for the natives.
With the latest support for the Bumiputras from the Government, it is time for the 9 unqualified Chinamen to call it quits.
Terrible decision ever, the man should check her transcript and see how she went thru her llb without failing core subjects. 1 whole batch witnessing this, and this babe never pass with 2nd class upper. All llb at iium graduated with honors, even 2nd class lower.
May lord helps this country from eternal doom.
Post a Comment