Tuesday, November 17, 2026

From Sungai Bakap to Melaka: Can PH Learn Before GE16?

Electoral Defeats Demand More Than Excuses

The successive electoral setbacks suffered by Pakatan Harapan (PH), from Sungai Bakap to Sabah, Johor, Negeri Sembilan and most recently Melaka, should have triggered serious political soul-searching.

Yet familiar explanations continue to surface; identity politics, hostile opponents, weak election machinery and voters failing to appreciate government achievements.

These explanations may contain elements of truth, but avoid a more uncomfortable question: Is PH losing because voters have changed, or because PH has failed to change since becoming the government?

Melaka provides a revealing lesson. PH won only four of 28 seats, all retained by DAP. PKR and Amanah failed to secure a single seat, including Bukit Katil, previously held by former chief minister Adly Zahari.

The result exposes a structural imbalance within PH that cannot be resolved merely through better campaigning.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Melaka State Election 2026 vs 2021: Comparative Analysis of Four DAP Seats

DAP Retained Its Seats, But Did It Retain Its Electoral Strength?

DAP leaders have understandably highlighted their success in defending all four seats in the November 14 Melaka state election. Vice-chairperson Teo Nie Ching described the results as reflecting continued confidence among voters of different ethnic backgrounds, particularly in the mixed constituency of Ayer Keroh.

On the surface, the claim has merit. DAP retained Bandar Hilir, Kota Laksamana, Ayer Keroh and Kesidang with comfortable winning majorities.

However, winning the same seats does not necessarily mean retaining the same level of electoral support.

A closer comparison with the 2021 state election reveals developments that deserve attention, particularly in the context of DAP's recent electoral experiences in Sabah, Johor and Negeri Sembilan.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Will Anwar Concede and Call for a Snap General Election?

The celebrations following BN's victory in Melaka had barely begun when supporters broke into a loud and unmistakable chant: “Bubar! Bubar! Bubar!”

After Johor, Negeri Sembilan and now Melaka, the call for an early general election reflects growing confidence among BN and PAS supporters.

The three state elections have unfolded remarkably close to what BN's political planners would have hoped for. Cooperation with PAS has delivered electoral gains, while Pakatan Harapan (PH) has struggled to expand beyond its traditional strongholds.

The question is whether Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim can afford to wait until economic and political conditions become more favourable, or whether circumstances may force him to reconsider his preferred timetable for GE16.

Friday, November 06, 2026

SSER Pipeline Saga: RM5 Billion Salvaged, But 8 Years Too Late for Accountability?

Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim deserves recognition for successfully negotiating a way out of the longstanding financial predicament involving the Trans-Sabah Gas Pipeline (TSGP) and Multi-Product Pipeline (MPP) projects.

The agreement reached with China Exim Bank on October 30, 2026 allows RM5 billion of the financing originally intended for the abandoned pipeline projects to be redirected towards the Northern Perak-Penang Water Supply Scheme.

It is not a refund of RM5 billion in cash. The financing obligation remains, but at least a substantial portion can now be utilised for something beneficial rather than continuing to burden the government without producing the intended infrastructure.

The original gas and petroleum pipeline projects will not be recommencing under this arrangement. Nevertheless, the agreement offers a practical solution to a longstanding water supply problem affecting northern Perak and Penang, with wider implications for agriculture, industrial development and the politics of interstate water resources involving Kedah.

Wednesday, November 04, 2026

When Rural Development Meets Fiscal Discipline: The KKDW-MOF Exchange (Part 2)

When Projects Exist on Paper

Before examining the current disagreement between the Ministry of Finance (MOF) and the Ministry of Rural and Regional Development (KKDW), I am reminded of an earlier experience. 

Before 2014, I was part of a team of investigative writers looking into rural infrastructure projects and allocations amounting to approximately RM7 billion. What we encountered was deeply troubling.

Water pipes had been delivered and piled up in villages, but nobody appeared concerned about installing them and ensuring that water reached the households. Electricity poles and cables had been erected, but there was no apparent effort to arrange and coordinate with Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd (SESB) to connect the installations to the grid and provide electricity.

Some village roads were merely compacted sand. They turned muddy after the first rainfall, yet were claimed and paid for as asphalt roads. Solar projects were claimed for payment despite not existing at the locations examined, where electricity generation continued to depend on diesel engines.

There were also mini-hydro schemes and water supply projects to rumah panjang where each stage of progress appeared to take place only after a state or general election. In other instances, annual road maintenance payments continued for roads that physically did not exist.

Monday, November 02, 2026

When Rural Development Meets Fiscal Discipline: The KKDW-MOF Exchange

A Financial Dispute Takes a Different Turn

What began as a dispute over financial administration between the Ministry of Finance (MOF) and the Ministry of Rural and Regional Development (KKDW) took a different turn when Deputy Prime Minister and Rural Development Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi raised concerns about projects in Sabah and Sarawak.

This article does not seek to examine the technicalities of government financial procedures, procurement or contract administration. Those are matters best left to professionals and practitioners familiar with the industry. The purpose here is to examine the arguments presented in Parliament, the issues brought to light and their implications for rural development and public accountability.

The original issue concerned KKDW's budget allocations, expenditure commitments and unpaid contractors. MOF had questioned how commitments could exceed the original allocations, while Zahid maintained that expenditure should be viewed against the revised allocations approved through the necessary financial processes.

The disagreement initially remained relatively contained. It attracted wider attention following an unusual public exchange between Zahid and MOF Secretary-General Johan Mahmood Merican, involving a minister and a senior civil servant from another ministry. 

Monday, October 26, 2026

Corporate Mafia: Cabinet Must Not Allow an Incomplete Investigation

Three Years of Exposés Must Not Be Forgotten

M Shanmugam’s column in The Edge Weekly dated October 26, 2026, “What happens after the corporate mafia probe is crucial”, raises a fundamental question: will the investigation expose the alleged Corporate Mafia in its entirety, or merely produce a report that leaves its principal operators and institutional connections untouched?

Another Brick in the Wall began writing about the corporate controversy surrounding Revenue Group Berhad in 2023, following the boardroom struggle and allegations of a forced corporate takeover. This was three years before Rafizi Ramli suddenly emerged as a prominent commentator on the Corporate Mafia, drawing on Bloomberg’s reporting on older cases and more recent developments. He should have investigated who the new owner of Revenue IF Berhad.

Nevertheless, Rafizi is entitled to raise these matters, but his recent interventions must not eclipse the work of those who have followed the controversy since its beginnings. Nor should the investigation be diverted into political and personal disputes involving Ramanan, Farhash, Azam Baki or others. 

Any credible allegations against them should be investigated on their merits, but the overriding objective must remain the alleged network associated with Victor Chin Boon Leong. The question is not who has the loudest political voice or the latest revelation. It is who allegedly built the network, how it operates, who protects it and who receives its financial rewards.

My Say