Electoral Defeats Demand More Than Excuses
The successive electoral setbacks suffered by Pakatan Harapan (PH), from Sungai Bakap to Sabah, Johor, Negeri Sembilan and most recently Melaka, should have triggered serious political soul-searching.
Yet familiar explanations continue to surface; identity politics, hostile opponents, weak election machinery and voters failing to appreciate government achievements.
These explanations may contain elements of truth, but avoid a more uncomfortable question: Is PH losing because voters have changed, or because PH has failed to change since becoming the government?
Melaka provides a revealing lesson. PH won only four of 28 seats, all retained by DAP. PKR and Amanah failed to secure a single seat, including Bukit Katil, previously held by former chief minister Adly Zahari.
The result exposes a structural imbalance within PH that cannot be resolved merely through better campaigning.






