Thursday, October 04, 2007
Musical Interlude: Goodbye England's Rose (Candle In The Wind 1997)
Goodbye England's Rose
May you ever grow in our hearts.
You were the grace that placed yourself
Where lives were torn apart.
You called out to our country,
And you whispered to those in pain.
Now you belong to heaven,
And the stars spell out your name.
And it seems to me you lived your life
Like a candle in the wind:
Never fading with the sunset
When the rain set in.
And your footsteps will always fall here,
Along England's greenest hills;
Your candle's burned out long before
Your legend ever will.
Loveliness we've lost;
These empty days without your smile.
This torch we'll always carry
For our nation's golden child.
And even though we try,
The truth brings us to tears;
All our words cannot express
The joy you brought us through the years.
And it seems to me you've lived your life
Like a candle in the wind:
Never fading with the sunset
When the rain set in.
And your footsteps will always fall here,
Along England's greenest hills;
Your candle's burned out long before
Your legend ever will.
Goodbye England's Rose
May you ever grow in our hearts.
You were the grace that placed yourself
Where lives were torn apart.
Goodbye England's Rose,
From a country lost without your soul,
Who'll miss the wings of your compassion
More than you will ever know.
And it seems to me you've lived your life
Like a candle in the wind:
Never fading with the sunset
When the rain set in.
And your footsteps will always fall here,
Along England's greenest hills;
Your candle's burned out long before
Your legend ever will.
-- ELton John
Tuesday, October 02, 2007
Do Right, Not Just Do Justice!
At the end of the legal drama film, The Winslow Boy, there was a profound dialogue about justice.The words of Sir Robert appropriately described the reality in the pursuit of justice. Hereon, justice will be written with open and close inverted comma.Sir Robert: ... I wept today because right had been done.
Catherine: Not justice?
Sir Robert: No. Not justice. Right. It is easy to do justice -- very hard to do right.
"Justice” is merely by-product or incidental from winning cases. In plain language, winning court cases does not necessarily assure “justice” is served. One lawyer’s inability to see a certain aspect of law results in an expensive loss to his or her client and justice is denied with ease.
It's this similar reality that perhaps brought about a cynical remark from Clarence Darrow, an early American civil libertarians, “There is no such thing as justice - in or out of court.” His winning streak against death penalty substantiates the point that he won out of his litigation ability. Was justice served?
One tongue and cheek description of "justice" claims it as the law and the law is men’s feeble attempt to lay down the principles of decency. Judges and lawyers as practitioners of law are attempting nothing more than a feeble attempt to be decent.
Perhaps the television tend to over-romanticised lawyers. LA Law TV series presented lawyers with glitz and glamour. In Law & Order TV Series, prosecutor McCoy is depicted as a man of ideal, persevering in the pursuit of “justice”. Lawyers potray themselves as champion of individual rights, defender of the Constitution, guardian of the oppressed, and advocate for clients’ principles.
Let's snap out of this perception and back to reality. At the practical level, most lawyers are not persons who know the law, but learned in finding the law that fits a given situation and the right angle to read it. Many, if not majority, are mouthpieces for their clients to speak in the foreign language of law. The ultimate sarcasm against lawyers is as hired guns sold to the highest bidder.Former US Chief Justice Warren Burger had this to say of the legal profession, “... ours is a sick profession marked by incompetence, lack of training, misconduct and bad manners. Ineptness, bungling, malpractice and bad ethics can be observed in court houses all over this country every day ... these incompetents have a seeming unawareness of the fundamental ethics of the profession.”
If that is the condition in the US, frankly ours does not fare any better or even worse. My lawyer did not turn up in court and I end up spending money for appeals. My friend’s wife’s lawyer came to an Industrial Court hearing unprepared. The story of lawyers absconding clients’ money is widespread.
Lawyers refuse clients in order to safeguard their Banking clients’ account. With every other lawyer having Banking clients, what hope is justice served for victims of powerful Bankers? This reminded me of the saga of Dato Idris Tulis and Bank Bumiputera. Back in mid 80s, one is reminded of a practicing lawyer making a RM16 million remittance steal from Bank Negara.
In the early days of this nation, lawyers are positioned at every other post in Government, Corporations and Politics. But, the country only made its quantum leap under the decisiveness and surgical precision of a doctor. Beyond the realm of law, there are those that feel the legal profession is over-rated.
Its difficult to do right, but easier to shout.
Nevertheless, last Thursday’s march by the Bar Council and lawyers at the Putrajaya deserve every shout for it demonstrate the right of people to an assembly esssential in a democratic process. The dismissal and denial of citizens’ right to gather and demonstrate with manipulative use of media and administrative limitation as excuses is unconstitutional.
The march should be supported not to give high regards for the Bar Council. The Bar Council has not met expectations to upgrade its professionalism in the profession, improve practices & procedure, discipline its errant members, and give much consideration to the legal consumers. Its own house is yet but in order and AGMs is infamous for quorum deficient. Sadly, the march itself is not representative of all Malaysian lawyers. Is there unclear and disunity in purpose? Lets hope the march does not represent certain interest groups.

The march should be supported for it should be symbolically interpreted as the people giving the system of “justice” the high esteem it deserve as a branch of government. All citizens, who believe in the need for a fair system of “justice”, to compliment the role of Parliament, and executive as branches of Government in our system of Constitutional Monarchy, should support any effort to do so.
The wrong done by other branches of Government could be corrected by a system of “justice”. For it pains, to see properties and assets of the common people acquired for the interest of faceless corporations. With ECER and NCER to come on stream, can the right of the Malay Reserve land owners safeguarded from the interest of the Might?
“Justice” should not be exclusive to judges, lawyers and intellectuals but to all Malaysian. This fight for “justice” should be free from unstated personal interest or for the benefit of any related genus. It certainly should not be hijacked for the interest of certain quarters of the legal fraternity. Nor should it be merely to serve the interest of minority interest and fringe groups at the expense of the right of the majority.
The fight for "justice" should not be padded with ulterior purpose to sway decisions in any way. Right should remain permanent. The fight for "justice" in the practise of religious freedom should not be at the expense of the right of Muslim majority, its institutions and aspirations. The rights of individual should not supercede the right of many, nor should the converse.
Let's just see right is done.
For that, lets not be lost in verbiages of slogan in this pursuit for the better. There is no need for anything new. Too much meaningless slogan for new has been let allowed - Melayu Baru and New Labor, to think of a few. Reform is just a dramatic slogan for new. Paradigm shift is seeking for something new out of the box, which seldom is.
Do not allow the discontinuation and uprooting of our history and tradition. For there, lies the closest to right. Beware! For every revolution, there lay deep hidden hands providing money in exchange for principal and interest.
If right could be achieved by something new, do so within the perimeters of evolution. Reform as slogan could be tolerable as long as right is done. Paradigm shift is fine if it could achieve more moves towards right. Perhaps, a paradigm shift for a Malaysian Law based on the spirit of the Rukunegara. Perhaps, a law that is clear on right and wrong which is embedded ethics and morality inherited to us by our cultural tradition, religion and history.
As time passes, the norms change together. Nothing should instill fear in us more than the morality of our forefathers compromised by time and changing norms. When gay and lesbian union and unmarried live in become common, will that be the basis of our law, supposedly written words of decency?
Decency and courtesy within our culture and psyche should be of paramount consideration in our pursuit for that elusive "justice". Wild accusation is wrong and ascribing guilt on those other than the responsible ones should be stopped. Until proven guilty, everyone is innocent. Being bold and righteous, does not mean compromise of ones courtesy and respect for others.
In the Court of Men, the Constitution is supreme but it should be taken as whole and not selective. The spirit in an article of law should be upheld together with the withstanding exceptions. Deep embedded within our constitution lies treaties, agreement and contracts that binds our past to the future. Its the continuity of our tradition as a free nation. And, its our solemn duty as Malaysians to uphold.
March on!
Do right, not just do justice!
Musical Intermission: Revolution
You say you want a revolution
Well, you know
We all want to change the world
You tell me that it's evolution
Well, you know
We all want to change the world
But when you talk about destruction
Don't you know that you can count me out
Don't you know it's gonna be all right
all right, all right
You say you got a real solution
Well, you know
We'd all love to see the plan
You ask me for a contribution
Well, you know
We're doing what we can
But when you want money
for people with minds that hate
All I can tell is brother you have to wait
Don't you know it's gonna be all right
all right, all right
Ah
ah, ah, ah, ah, ah...
You say you'll change the constitution
Well, you know
We all want to change your head
You tell me it's the institution
Well, you know
You better free you mind instead
But if you go carrying pictures of chairman Mao
You ain't going to make it with anyone anyhow
Don't you know it's gonna be all right
all right, all right
all right, all right, all right
all right, all right, all right
-- The Beatles
Sunday, September 30, 2007
Mencari Lailatulqadr?
Bulan Ramadhan kini sudah menghampiri kemuncaknya. Pemikiran popular menggalakkan orang ramai sekurang-kurangnya mempertingkatkan amalan ibadah pada 10 hari terakhir Ramadhan untuk mendapatkan Lailatulqadr. Banyak kisah-kisah mitos yang telah merosakkan pemahaman masyarakat mengenai Lilatulqadr. Apakah sebenarnya Lailatulaadr? Apa yang dicari dalam Lailatulqadr?Mohd Shauki Abdul Majid, Pengurus Penyelidikkan YADIM memberi penjelasan kepada inipati Lailatulqadr dalam rencananya, "Simbolisme Malam Lailatulqadar "yang tersiar di Utusan Malaysia September 20hb, 2007 dibawah ini:
DISEBABKAN lailatulqadar ini abstrak, bersifat spiritual dan rohaniah dan tidak boleh dipastikan melalui kajian maka timbullah pendapat yang pelbagai mengenainya. Pelbagai cerita mitos terbit ketika lailatulqadar turun iaitu seperti air sungai berhenti mengalir, pohon-pohon serta tumbuhan tunduk tenang, alam maya kelihatan cerah dan sebagainya.
Justeru lailatulqadar ini kita dapatkan asas legalitasinya dalam al-Quran, maka selayaknya ia memberi tanda-tanda itu agar tidak terjadi penyelewengan dan menimbulkan cerita-cerita karut dan tidak masuk akal. Bagaimana sebenarnya al-Quran berbicara soal tanda- tanda lailatulqadar ini?
Di dalam surah Al-Qadar (97) ayat terakhir Allah s.w.t. menyebut tanda-tandanya: "Sa laamun hiya hatta matla‘il fajr”–kedamaian atau kenikmatan hakiki (terjadi) pada malam itu hingga terbit fajar. Jadi jelas tandanya tidak bersifat lahiriah kerana kedamaian itu adalah sesuatu yang dirasakan. Hakikatnya sesiapa yang mendapatkan lailatulqadar, akan berasa kedamaian atau ketenangan yang luar biasa dalam dirinya pada malam itu hingga terbit fajar. Justeru itu di dalam surah ad Dukhan (44) ayat 3 lailatulqadar disebut Laylatun mubaarakah kerana kedamaian hati yang bersumber terus daripada Allah adalah berkat yang paling tinggi. Ia bagaikan air sejuk bagi musafir yang kehausan.
Al-Quran adalah sumber pengetahuan tertinggi dan kerananya, kebenarannya tidak diragukan. Ia hanya dapat dicapai melalui darjat intelektual paling tinggi iaitu intelek kenabian. Sekurang-kurangnya jika kita dapat sekadar percikannya (saja) pada malam lailatulqadar bermakna mujahadah kita waktu itu sekurang-kurangnya berhasil menyentuh intelek kenabian. Dan itulah kenikmatan dan sekali gus berkat yang paling tinggi. Nilainya pasti lebih mulia dari seribu bulan.
Inilah malam yang sangat dinantikan oleh umat Islam, malam yang penuh barakah dan lebih baik dari seribu bulan. Pada malam itu turun rahmat dan kebaikan daripada Allah kepada umat-Nya. Pengalaman mendapatkan lailatulqadar merupakan pengalaman spiritual dan individual. Tidak semua orang mampu mendapatkannya. Ia tidak boleh dicapai hanya dengan kehadiran kita pada malam-malam ganjil 10 malam terakhir Ramadan.Apa dan bagaimanakah malam lailatulqadar itu? Apakah ia terjadi sekali sahaja yakni malam ketika turunnya al-Quran atau terjadi setiap bulan Ramadan? Ada pendapat sesetengah ulama bahawa malam lailatulqadar juga berlaku pada malam nisfu Syaaban. Walau bagaimanapun yang pasti ia harus diimani oleh setiap Muslim berdasarkan firman Allah di dalam surah al-Dukhan (ayat 3 - 5) yang bermaksud:
Sesungguhnya Kami menurunkannya (al-Quran) pada suatu malam dan sesungguhnya Kami-lah yang memberi peringatan. Pada malam itu dijelaskan semua urusan yang penuh hikmah, iaitu urusan yang besar di sisi Kami.
Pakar hadis, Ibnu Hajar menyebut riwayat dari penganut fahaman di atas menyatakan, Nabi pernah bersabda, malam lailatulqadar tidak akan datang lagi.
Pendapat tersebut ditolak oleh majoriti ulama kerana mereka berpegang pada teks ayat al-Quran serta sekian banyak teks hadis yang menunjukkan lailatulqadar terjadi pada setiap Ramadan. Bahkan Rasulullah menganjurkan umatnya mempersiapkan jiwa menyambut malam mulia itu, secara khusus pada malam-malam ganjil setelah berlalu 20 Ramadan.
Suatu ketika Rasulullah bersabda kepada umatnya yang sedang berkumpul di masjid menunggu lailatulqadar. Sabdanya: Apa yang kamu tunggu-tunggu malam ini akan datang kerana aku telah melihat dalam visi (rukyah) bahawa akan berlaku hujan lebat kemudian aku berlumuran lumpur dan basah kuyup oleh air. Kemudian mereka yang berkumpul itu bersurai. Ternyata malam itu memang terjadi hujan lebat.
Justeru bangunan masjid di zaman Nabi diperbuat daripada daun kurma maka air hujan mudah menitis masuk ke dalam lantai masjid yang bertanah. Umat Islam yang ada pada saat kejadian itu melihat apa yang dikatakan Nabi. Nabi dengan mukanya yang basah kuyup dan badan berlumuran tanah liat. Lalu apa yang dimaksud dengan lailatulqadar oleh Nabi? Kerana Nabi mengatakan “Itulah yang kau tunggu-tunggu.” Justeru lailatulqadar adalah persoalan rohani, maka tidak ada kata-kata yang mapan untuk menjelaskan. Ia hanya boleh diungkap melalui simbol atau metafora.
Di sinilah timbul masalah tafsir dan takwil di mana Nabi dengan lumpur dan basah dengan air sebenarnya adalah suatu peringatan kepada kita bahawa tingkat paling tinggi dari pengalaman rohani itu ialah kalau kita sudah kembali ke asal kita.
Ini semuanya mensyaratkan adanya kesedaran untuk kembali kepada Allah. Pulang kepada Allah itu kemudian dimulai dengan pulang ke tanah. Jadi yang dialami Nabi ialah satu simbolisasi bahawa kita pun akan kembali ke tanah, juga kembali menjadi air.
Tidak ada kebahagiaan yang ingin dicapai melainkan kebahagiaan hakiki di sisi Allah. Inilah yang kita cari dalam tahap rohani puasa ini yang kita alami melalui satu simbolisasi dari lailatulqadar. Tetapi semuanya memang harus dimulai dengan tanah dan air dengan kata lain, kesedaran tentang diri kita yang sesungguhnya.
Jika orang yang ikhlas ada tandanya, maka demikian juga orang yang mendapat lailatulqadar pasti ada tandanya jua. Pertama, apakah kita sudah semakin memahami maksud-maksud suci Allah ketika membaca al-Quran? Kedua, apakah ibadat kita sudah lebih banyak, lebih baik, dan nikmatnya? Ketiga, apakah kita melihat manusia sebagai satu kesatuan tanpa dipilih oleh mana- mana mahzab? Keempat, apakah kita sudah berasa jijik melakukan dosa dan maksiat? Kelima, apakah kita bersedia berlapang dada memaafkan musuh kita?Keenam, jika kita berada dalam kesibukan tetapi banyak melakukan amal ibadah dan zikir dengan tidak mempunyai apa-apa yang harus dibanggakan di hadapan Allah? Ini semua bererti kemungkinan besar kita berhasil mendapat curahan berkat-Nya melalui lailatulqadar.Wallahu alam bissawwab.
Muga setiap anda memahami dan menenemui Lailatulqadr masing-masing.
Saturday, September 29, 2007
Poetic Intermission: Desiderata
Go placidly amid the noise and haste,
and remember what peace there may be in silence.
As far as possible without surrender
be on good terms with all persons.
Speak your truth quietly and clearly;
and listen to others,
even the dull and the ignorant;
they too have their story.
Avoid loud and aggressive persons,
they are vexations to the spirit.
If you compare yourself with others,
you may become vain and bitter;
for always there will be greater and lesser persons than yourself.
Enjoy your achievements as well as your plans.
Keep interested in your own career, however humble;
it is a real possession in the changing fortunes of time.
Exercise caution in your business affairs;
for the world is full of trickery.
But let this not blind you to what virtue there is;
many persons strive for high ideals;
and everywhere life is full of heroism.
Be yourself.
Especially, do not feign affection.
Neither be cynical about love;
for in the face of all aridity and disenchantment
it is as perennial as the grass.
Take kindly the counsel of the years,
gracefully surrendering the things of youth.
Nurture strength of spirit to shield you in sudden misfortune.
But do not distress yourself with dark imaginings.
Many fears are born of fatigue and loneliness.
Beyond a wholesome discipline,
be gentle with yourself.
You are a child of the universe,
no less than the trees and the stars;
you have a right to be here.
And whether or not it is clear to you,
no doubt the universe is unfolding as it should.
Therefore be at peace with God,
whatever you conceive Him to be,
and whatever your labors and aspirations,
in the noisy confusion of life keep peace with your soul.
With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams,
it is still a beautiful world.
Be cheerful.
Strive to be happy.
-- Max Ehrmann (1927)
A recent event reminded me of this lifelong gift from my late English teacher. I have cherish and literally tried to uphold to its every word.
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Ekonomi Merdeka Bukan Liberalisasi Melulu
Apa yang sedang dilalui oleh kebanyakan negara Barat terutamanya Amerika Syarikat semenjak krisis “sub-prime mortgage” melanda sepatutnya membuka mata kita rakyat Malaysia. Krisis perbankan ini memang sudah lama dihidu, yang menjadi tanda tanya ialah sejauh mana impaknya kepada ekonomi AS dan ekonomi dunia.Ramai yang berpendapat walaupun Federal Reserve atau lebih kenali sebagai Fed, sudah pun memotong kadar faedah sebanyak 50 mata, tapi tindakan ini seolah-olah mengiayakan teori bahawa AS adalah diambang kelumpuhan ekonomi.
Kalau mengikut petunjuk ekonomi, sepatutnya sudah lama ekonomi AS lumpuh dengan defisit kembar dalam akaun imbangan bayaran dan badget tahunannya. Berapa lama ekonomi AS dan nilai Dollarnya boleh bertahan adalah untuk tekaan semua? Buat ketika ini, hanya harga minyak mentah yang tinggi sahaja dapat mengapungkan nilai Dollar.
Namun, penulis sebenarnya lebih berminat melihat reaksi pendukung-pendukung ekonomi AS dari Rumah Putih, ahli akademik, ahli korporat, ahli perbankan dan media massa mereka bila berhadapan dengan krisis yang makin meruncing ini. Bandingkan pula apa reaksi mereka 9 tahun yang lepas semasa negara kita menghadapi krisis kewangan dan matawang Asia 1998.
Politikus dan media massa AS begitu cepat mengutuk dan memperkecilkan hampir kesemua yang negara kita dan jiran-jiran “Ekonomi Harimau” lakukan. Walaupun sebelum ini, pertumbuhan ekonomi begitu baik dirantau Asia Tenggara yang diransang oleh dasar ekonomi yang baik, namun negara-negara ini dihujani dan dituduh sebagai negara korup yang dasar ekonominya selama ini silap semuanya.
Begitu kuat tuduhan ini sehingga ada pihak yang beranggapan bahawa negara-negara ini wajar “diajar” supaya lebih berdisiplin. Tuduhan dan gembar-gembur ini lebih mendorong kepada panik dan hilang keyakinan yang menjadikan krisis matawang itu bertambah teruk. Spekulator matawang menggunakan peluang ini untuk mencipta dan menambah keuntungan mereka.
Syukurlah ketika itu negara ini dikemudi oleh Tun Dr. Mahathir, Perdana Menteri yang tidak mudah menyerah kalah dan menerima tohmahan orang luar begitu sahaja. Walaupun diasak dari luar dan dalam untuk menerima “ubat pahit” yang dibawa oleh IMF termasuk menaikkan kadar faedah yang amat tidak masuk akal (pada suatu ketika mencecah 18 peratus) dan mengetatkan kecairan kewangan, Tun lebih yakin dengan ubat buatan sendiri yang nyata lebih mujarab untuk negara ini dalam bentuk Kawalan Dana/Matawang terpilih (Selective Capital Control).
Ketika itu ramai (termasuk bekas Menteri Kewangan dan Gabenor Bank Negara) yang begitu obses dengan cadangan pakar luar terutamanya dari IMF dan Bank Dunia yang mahukan negara ini mengamalkan liberalisasi ekonomi yang menyeluruh. Sejarah menjadi hakim yang adil. Kejayaan negara mengekang kelumpuhan ekonomi dan keadaan kacau bilau (seperti di negara jiran) tanpa menyerah diri kepada IMF dan mengamalkan liberalisasi ekonomi sepatutnya dijadikan antara highlite penting dalam kita menyambut 50 tahun kemerdekaan. Kedegilan pemimpin nombor satu negara yang amat patriotik ketika itu menjamin kesenambungan kemerdekaan ekonomi Malaysia . Kejayaan kita ini akhirnya diakui juga oleh IMF sendiri dan pakar ekonomi seperti Ethan Kaplan & Dani Rodrick dari Harvard University melalui kertas kerja mereka “Did the Malaysian Capital Control Work?”.
Ternyata setelah hampir 9 tahun, kita sedar betapa hipokrit-hipokrit dari dunia Barat ini tidak pernah ikhlas dan hanya mahu mengambil kesempatan dari kelemahan kita. UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) sendiri baru-baru ini memberi amaran betapa bahayanya liberalisasi kewangan tanpa kawalan kepada negara membangun.
Dengan keterbukaan pasaran kewangan, aktiviti spekulasi dan pelaburan berisiko tinggi akan lebih senang menjerut ekonomi negara membangun ini. Dengan modal yang begitu besar, spekulator ini boleh bebas menaik dan menurunkan matawang dan pasaran kewangan mana-mana negara mengikut kehendak mereka. Disamping itu, dengan liberalisasi kewangan mutlak ini juga, ekonomi kita akan begitu bergantung kepada ekonomi negara mereka.
Lihatlah juga bagaimana langkah mereka apabila berhadapan dengan krisis ekonomi. Walaupun dulu mereka mahu kita diajar disiplin ekonomi sehingga mahu dibiarkan sahaja syarikat dan bank yang menghadapi masalah menjadi bangkrap, namun apabila perkara yang sama berlaku kepada mereka, bukan sahaja mereka ini di “bail-out” (seperti apa yang berlaku kepada LTCM dan bank-bank mereka), kadar faedah juga diturunkan dan suntikan kewangan berbillion dollar dilakukan untuk menjamin kecairan dipasaran kewangan mereka. Begitu berlawanan dengan apa yang mereka mahu kita lakukan 9 tahun yang lalu. Kenapa bank-bank mereka tidak dibiarkan sahaja bangkrap?
Marilah kita belajar untuk menjadi degil, sekiranya berbuat begitu memberi lebih kebaikan kepada negara dan bangsa kita sendiri. Tidak perlu terlalu mendengar nasihat tidak ikhlas dari hipokrit-hipokrit besar ini baik dari dalam mahu pun luar negara. Semoga dengan itu Malaysia akan lebih merdeka dalam erti kata yang sebenar-benarnya.
Adakah akhirnya kita tinggal berharap?
Ekonomi negara kini sedang diliberalisasi secara melulu atas pengaruh Menantu, operatif Tingkat 4 dan pemikir mereka seperti Ethos Consulting. Tindakan yang dilakukan begitu membahayakan terhadap kepentingan masa depan rakyat serta keselamatan negara. Kita pula menghadapi Perdana Menteri begitu cetek aptitude dan lemah kebolehan pengurusan. Manakala, yang menjadi penasihat mereka hanya tahu memainkan ungkapan "copycat", satu terma yang begitu lumrah diperkenalkan oleh seorang ahli Panel Penasihat Wilayah Pembngunan Iskandar, Tun Musa Hitam.Fikirkan ...
Monday, September 24, 2007
Parental Negligent and Abuse is Real
If the IGP Tan Sri Musa Hasan, Dato Shahrizat and Dato Nazri was wronged and labeled as “bodoh” by some commentators in Nuraina Samad’s blog here, it is perhaps due to their poor timing and insensitive remarks. Perhaps it is out of sympathy and anger, knowing the couple had suffered enough for their lackadaisical attitude. I am not about to echo the IGP and Minister and be their apologist. However, fact is fact and they are right.
Having undergone a legal battle involving the Child Protection Act, I am quite aware the existence of such law. There is such law to protect children from negligent and abusive parents. Negligent and abusive parents exist and are quite prevalent in this country!
I am not unsympathetic but fact is fact. In the case of Nurin Jazlin, the parents were partly to blame to allow her to roam the night market by herself unaccompanied and unmonitored. What more with a child sex molester widely known to be roaming the area. The lapse in attention by Jazimin Abdul Jalil and his wife, Norazian Bistaman lead to the death of their 8-year old daughter. Some parents do take things for granted and they should be made aware of such danger.
It is unfair for many parties to lay the responsibility on the police when some parents have shirked from their responsibility to take the necessary precaution. In a city of few million people, finding a lost 8-year old is almost like finding a rusted needle in a pile of haystack. What more with piling cases and insufficient resources. The police can be seek to help but the first party of responsibility lies with the parents.
Assuming there is no politics in play, the statement by the IGP and Ministers should be taken factually. It’s most unlikely Nurin Jazlin's parents will be charged. Perhaps, it is necessary to be brutally honest to make the public more aware that parental negligence is an offense under the Child Protection Act. Negligent and also abusive parents pose danger to children and it goes beyond just their physical, emotional and psychological well being but even death. The impact of abusive parents is more vicious as per the maxim "abuse children grow up to be abusive parents".
The Child Protection Act covers for parental responsibility to provide for food, clothing, and schools. It includes monitoring, guiding and supervising children’s physical, educational, emotional and spiritual development. It is not easily enforceble for the law to cover for poor parenting skill, but there is sufficient provision for parental apathy towards their responsibility.Based on the observations of both my teacher-parents, neglected children tend to be playful, lack disciplien and as a result do poorly in school. Common indication of negligent or poor parenting are children allowed to roam free out of their home and their play activity left uncurtailed. The unsupervised and unmonitored freedom given to children is the root cause that later lead to other adolescence problems like indiscipline, gangsterism, drugs, sexual promiscuity, and others.
Surmise to say, parental neglect is the root cause and contributing factor of social ill amongst youth. Despite the affluence of society of today, the problems of parental neglect, that is assumed as common in the lower economic class, are now common occurrence amongst higher end of society.
Is the Child Protection Act of 2001 effective? Perhaps its worth sharing the experiance of my own battle in the courts to save few children from abusive parent and step parent few years ago. Our attempt to save the children had the only option to seek their removal from the abusive parent. Alas it was denied because of inadequate law.
The law only give living parent the locus standi for guardianship. There is no or too stringent provisions and process to remove the parental right of negligent and abusive parents and to award child custody to other family members. What hope is there to safe the children when the court allowed for the children to live under the same roof with the abusive parents? What hope to protect children when they couldn't distinguish between capital punishment and child abuse? Although there are avenues under syariah law, indifference was another insurmountable barrier we faced.
Since the incident, the physical abuse has lessen. However, there is no guarantee that their suffering has reduced. It merely changed from physical abuse to emotional and psychological abuse and from abuse to neglect. With the parent more aware of their rights, the burden of proof on the Welfare Department is heavier should the abuse occur again.
It was a frustating situation. Till today, I keep wondering whether the Ministry of Welfare, Family Development and Women Affair has the necessary steps to make it difficult to remove parental right of negligent and abusive parents. Is it sufficient to merely hope the abusive parents volunteer to attend counselling? Is there sufficient resources to organise such counselling session? Is the Welfare Department's far in-between surprise checks sufficients to monitor the children's welfare and their education? With limited budget allocation available for Welfare Department, is there sufficient capacity for them?
Family development is nucleus for human development. Has the era of “Bapa Pembangunan Modal Insan” evolve into any significant progress in this area? I have always had reservation of the human resource development strategy in the RMK9, which is merely sloganised education development. One can't expect the strategy to look at family development as important. The same vicious circle of negligence and abuse will only repeat itself.
My fatihah and prayers to Allahyarhamah Nur Jazlin and all the victimised children of negligent and abusive parents.
My Say
-
▼
2026
(39)
-
▼
November
(6)
- From Sungai Bakap to Melaka: Can PH Learn Before G...
- Melaka State Election 2026 vs 2021: Comparative An...
- Will Anwar Concede and Call for a Snap General Ele...
- SSER Pipeline Saga: RM5 Billion Salvaged, But 8 Ye...
- When Rural Development Meets Fiscal Discipline: Th...
- When Rural Development Meets Fiscal Discipline: Th...
-
▼
November
(6)

